A Change.org petition is urging the International Olympic Committee to revoke Caitlyn Jenner’s 1976 gold medal — and, scarier, people seem to be pretty on board with it. The petition launched only three days ago has already raked in nearly 12,000 supporters. Jennifer Bradford of Fort Worth, Texas claims that, because Jenner now openly identifies as a woman, she owes it to the transgender community to forfeit her gold.

Despite amassing nearly 12,000 supporters in under three days, the International Olympic Committee is looking on